Improper integrals
in Calculus Answers by

Your answer

Your name to display (optional):
Privacy: Your email address will only be used for sending these notifications.
Anti-spam verification:
To avoid this verification in future, please log in or register.

1 Answer

The behaviour of this function f(x)=cos(x)cos(x^2) is interesting. The integral is the area between the curve and the x axis. If the functions cos(x) and -cos(x) are plotted on the same graph, the latter form an envelope for f(x). Between x=(pi)/2 and 3(pi)/2, the curve has 4 maxima and 3 minima; between x=3(pi)/2 and 5(pi)/2 there are 7 maxima and 6 minima; between x=(2n-1)(pi)/2 and (2n+1)(pi)/2 there are 3n+1 maxima and 3n minima (integer n>0), a total of 6n+1. (These are based purely on observation, and need to be supported by sound mathematical deduction.) As n becomes large the envelope appears to fill as the extrema become closer together. As x tends to infinity n also tends to infinity. The envelope apparently has as much area above (positive) as below (negative) the x axis so the total area will be zero as the positive and negative areas cancel out.

The question is: do the areas cancel out exactly? As x gets larger, the curve starts to develop irregularities and patterns, but it stays within the envelope, and positive irregularities appear to be balanced by negative irregularities, so the overall symmetry appears to be preserved.

f(x)=0 when cos(x)=0 or cos(x^2)=0, which means that x=(2n-1)(pi)/2 or sqrt((2n-1)(pi)/2), where n>0. Between 3(pi)/2 and 5(pi)/2, for example, we have sqrt(3(pi)/2), sqrt(5(pi)/2), ..., sqrt(13(pi)/2), because sqrt(13(pi)/2)<3(pi)/2<sqrt(15(pi)/2), there are 6 zeroes created by the square roots plus two more by the end points. The extrema fall in between the zeroes, making 7 extrema in all. So, for n=1, there are 7 extrema between (2n-1)(pi)/2 and (2n+1)(pi)/2. Taking the inequality above, we can write: 13(pi)/2<9(pi)^2/4<15(pi)/2 or 13<9(pi)/2<15. Between 3(pi)/2 and 5(pi)/2 we have sqrt(15(pi)/2), sqrt(17(pi)/2), ..., sqrt(39(pi)/2), 13 zeroes plus the 2 end points=15 zeroes, so for n=2 there are 14 extrema; 39<25(pi)/2<41. For n=3, 75<49(pi)/2<77; n=4, 127<81(pi)/2<129. 

The endpoint (the quantity at the centre of the inequality) is given by (2m+1)^2(pi)/2, where integer m>0, and this lies between (2n-1) and (2n+1); so n is defined by 2n-1<(2m+1)^2(pi)/2<2n+1. 

For m-1 we have 2(n-z)-1<(2m-1)^2(pi)/2<2(n-z)+1, where z is related to the number of zeroes in the current "batch". For example, take m=3: 2n-1<49(pi)/2<2n+1; 49(pi)/2=76.97 approx., so 2n-1=75, and n=38. Also 2(n-z)-1<25(pi)/2<2(n-z)+1 so, because 25(pi)/2=39.27 approx., 2(n-z)+1=41, n-z=20, and z=18. When m=2, 2n-1=39, n=20; 2(20-z)-1<9(pi)/2<2(20-z)+1; 2(20-z)-1=13, 20-z=7, z=13. The actual number of zeroes, Z, including the end points is 2 more than this: Z=z+2. Now we have an exact way to calculate the number of zeroes in each batch. So Z and n are both related to m. The number of extrema, E=Z-1=z+1. In fact, E=int(2(pi)(m-1)+1), where int(a) means the integer part of a, so as m increases, there are proportionately more extrema over the range (2m-1)(pi)/2 to (2m+1)(pi)/2. The figure of 6n+1 deduced earlier by observation approximates to the mathematical findings, because 2(pi) is approximately equal to 6.

But we still need to show, or disprove, that the areas above and below the x axis are equal and therefore cancel out. Unfortunately, if we consider the area under the first maximum (between x=(pi)/2 and sqrt(3(pi)/2)), and the area above the first minimum (between x=sqrt(3(pi)/2) and sqrt(5(pi)/2)), they are not the same, so do not cancel out.

More...

by Top Rated User (1.1m points)
reshown by

Related questions

1 answer
1 answer
asked Apr 26, 2013 in Calculus Answers by anonymous | 728 views
1 answer
asked Jun 18, 2013 in Calculus Answers by anonymous | 746 views
0 answers
asked Feb 5, 2013 in Algebra 2 Answers by anonymous | 483 views
1 answer
asked Feb 5, 2013 in Algebra 2 Answers by anonymous | 832 views
1 answer
1 answer
asked Dec 12, 2013 in Calculus Answers by anonymous | 3.4k views
1 answer
asked Jul 21, 2013 in Calculus Answers by asodisen Level 1 User (120 points) | 659 views
2 answers
asked Jun 19, 2013 in Calculus Answers by anonymous | 929 views
1 answer
asked May 14, 2013 in Calculus Answers by anonymous | 2.7k views
1 answer
1 answer
asked Feb 16, 2013 in Calculus Answers by anonymous | 791 views
0 answers
1 answer
asked Jan 31, 2013 in Calculus Answers by anonymous | 614 views
Welcome to MathHomeworkAnswers.org, where students, teachers and math enthusiasts can ask and answer any math question. Get help and answers to any math problem including algebra, trigonometry, geometry, calculus, trigonometry, fractions, solving expression, simplifying expressions and more. Get answers to math questions. Help is always 100% free!
87,551 questions
99,638 answers
2,417 comments
441,977 users