Show that the plane 3x+y-z=4 touches the ellipsoid 2z^2=(√7) (1-2x^2-y^2)
in Geometry Answers by Level 2 User (1.3k points)

Your answer

Your name to display (optional):
Privacy: Your email address will only be used for sending these notifications.
Anti-spam verification:
To avoid this verification in future, please log in or register.

1 Answer

What I'm trying to do here is to establish the gradients of the ellipsoid and the plane. The plane has only one gradient (in any particular direction) whereas the ellipsoid gradient varies over the surface. Where the ellipsoid surface has the same gradient as the fixed gradient of the plane gives us point(s) on the surface. This means that the plane and the gradient (tangent) of the ellipsoid are parallel, when the gradient of the ellipsoid is measured in the same direction as the plane. The plane touches the ellipsoid only if they meet, that is, the coordinates of the ellipsoid at the surface match coordinates lying on the plane. 

[In the following, I may not be able to give you the whole proof, due to my unfamiliarity with this type of problem, but I have an intuition regarding the essence of the solution. I hope that you will be able to glean enough for you to pursue the solution yourself.]

Let w=-sqrt(7)(1-2x^2-y^2)+2z^2. grad(w)=<4xsqrt(7),2ysqrt(7),4z>. This is derived from the differentials of the variable terms.

grad(w) at point P(a,b,c) is grad(w)|P=<4asqrt(7),2bsqrt(7),4c>, making the tangent plane:

4asqrt(7)(x-a)+2bsqrt(7)(y-b)+4c(z-c)=0 or 4asqrt(7)x+2bsqrt(7)y+4cz=4a^2sqrt(7)+2b^2sqrt(7)+4c^2.

The point P also lies on the plane: 3a+b-c=4, if the ellipsoid touches the plane. So, c=3a+b-4.

P must lie on the ellipsoid, so if a and b are set, c^2=z^2=(1-2a^2-b^2)sqrt(7)/2.

[However, if z=0, it is easier to find values for b and c on the surface of the ellipsoid. Such values are given by 2x^2+y^2=1, an ellipse itself. So P(a,sqrt(1-2a^2),0) is such a point. The tangential plane is 4asqrt(7)x+2sqrt(7(1-2a^2))y=4a^2sqrt(7)+2(1-2a^2) and 3a+sqrt(1-2a^2)-4=0 if P lies on the plane. So sqrt(1-2a^2)=4-3a must be satisfied. 1-2a^2=16-24a+9a^2, 11a^2-24a+15=0, which has no real solutions, so we cannot start with c=0, and we need to continue with the general case.]

With P(a,b,sqrt((1-2a^2-b^2)sqrt(7)/2)), (3a+b-4)^2=(1-2a^2-b^2)sqrt(7)/2, equating the squares of the z coords for the tangential plane and the given plane.

9a^2+6a(b-4)+b^2-8b+16=(1-2a^2-b^2)sqrt(7)/2.

9a^2+6ab-24+b^2-8b+16=sqrt(7)-a^2sqrt(7)-b^2sqrt(7)/2.

a^2(9+sqrt(7))+6ab+(b^2(1+sqrt(7)/2)-8b-8-sqrt(7))=0.

The discriminant is 36b^2-4(9+sqrt(7))(b^2(1+sqrt(7)/2)-8b-8-sqrt(7))=

36b^2-36b^2-36b^2sqrt(7)/2+288b+288+36sqrt(7)-4sqrt(7)b^2-14b^2+32sqrt(7)b+32sqrt(7)+28=

-4b^2(9sqrt(7)/2+sqrt(7)+7/2)+32b(9+sqrt(7))+316+68sqrt(7).

The discriminant must be positive for real a (for example if b=0).

[If b=0, P(a,0,sqrt((1-2a^2)sqrt(7)/2)) is the common point, (3a-4)^2=(1-2a^2)sqrt(7)/2.

9a^2-8a+16=(1-2a^2)sqrt(7)/2, a^2(9+sqrt(7))-8a+16-sqrt(7)/2=0.

The discriminant for this is 64-2(9+sqrt(7))(32-sqrt(7)) which is negative, so b cannot be 0.]

This "solution" is clearly becoming over-complicated and I suspect it's the wrong approach. Perhaps you will be able to take some of the ideas and develop them more elegantly. If I find a better method I will come back to this problem. Sorry for any inconvenience.

 

 

by Top Rated User (1.1m points)
I think there is a problem with this question as I've also got an complicated solution with no firm answer
I would agree, there is a problem.

I've been searching online, and I found this at

https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=mRY8BAAAQBAJ&pg=PA52&lpg=PA52&dq=tangent+plane+conicoid&source=bl&ots=_FBZLfhti0&sig=UanDLKUCFyeXmI9pNBg4AppyDYs&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiyk5qs86bLAhVDWBoKHSxlAQwQ6AEILjAE#v=onepage&q=tangent%20plane%20conicoid&f=false

page 11.52, Section 11.41 Condition of Tangency, Eq (4).

The plane lx + my + nz = p touches the conicoid ax^2 + by^2 + cz^2 = 1 if

l^2/a + m^2/b + n^2/c = p^2  ----------- (1)

You have lx + my + nz = p from 3x+y-z=4, and ax^2 + by^2 + cz^2 = 1 from 2z^2=(√7) (1-2x^2-y^2), or 2x^2 + y^2 + [2/(√7)]z^2 = 1 giving

l = 3, m = 1, n = -1, p = 4; a = 2, b = 1, c = [2/(√7)]

These coefficient values don'e work with the Tangency Equation (1)

Looks like some of the coefficient values are out.

Related questions

1 answer
asked Feb 26, 2016 in Geometry Answers by karan91 Level 2 User (1.3k points) | 1.2k views
1 answer
asked Feb 26, 2016 in Geometry Answers by karan91 Level 2 User (1.3k points) | 2.0k views
1 answer
1 answer
asked Mar 2, 2016 in Geometry Answers by karan91 Level 2 User (1.3k points) | 707 views
1 answer
asked Feb 26, 2016 in Geometry Answers by karan91 Level 2 User (1.3k points) | 1.4k views
1 answer
asked Feb 26, 2016 in Geometry Answers by karan91 Level 2 User (1.3k points) | 675 views
1 answer
asked Feb 26, 2016 in Geometry Answers by karan91 Level 2 User (1.3k points) | 1.0k views
1 answer
1 answer
1 answer
2 answers
asked May 7, 2013 in Geometry Answers by anonymous | 896 views
1 answer
asked Mar 10, 2016 in Geometry Answers by beginner | 715 views
1 answer
asked Sep 10, 2012 in Geometry Answers by anonymous | 727 views
Welcome to MathHomeworkAnswers.org, where students, teachers and math enthusiasts can ask and answer any math question. Get help and answers to any math problem including algebra, trigonometry, geometry, calculus, trigonometry, fractions, solving expression, simplifying expressions and more. Get answers to math questions. Help is always 100% free!
87,542 questions
99,804 answers
2,417 comments
522,584 users